An overview of the history and theory of transformative justice anthony j. National security seminar at harvard university december 2001 on file with. However, transitional justice becomes understood as both extraordinary and international in the postwar period after 1945. Iavor rangelov discussing globalizing transitional justice oup, 2015 friday, 4 december at 12. The term transitional justice has come, in recent years, to designate a field of academic inquiry, as well as political practice, concerned with the aftermath of conflict and largescale human rights abuses. Transitional justice takes this question to a new level with an interdisciplinary approach that challenges the very terms of the contemporary debate. Interest in transitional justice has surged in legal scholarship, in the human rights field generally and most notably in the domain of politics. Teitel genealogies i coined the term transitional justice 1 to account for the selfconscious construction of a distinctive conception of justice associated with periods of. Ictjbrookings transitional justice responses to palestinian dispossession a snapshot of palestinian dispossession in israel in the six decades since the start of the israelipalestinian conflict, there have been two major waves. An erudite, ambitious and optimistic book, ruti teitels humanitys law argues that a transformation is taking place in the international legal order that constitutes a fundamental. This book proposes an idea of transitional justice mechanisms in order to portrait society problems under the democratic transition countries. Thank you for joining jasmina brankovic and sufiya bray of the centre for the study of violence and reconciliation csvr, galuh wandita and patrick burgess of the asia justice and rights ajar and the new tactics online community for this discussion on transitional justice in practice that took place on may 12 to may 23, 2014.
The verdict has addressed some of the key issues and controversies that were. Transitional justice consists of judicial and nonjudicial measures implemented in order to redress legacies of human rights abuses. Traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional justice oup 2000. An empirical evaluation of transitional justice scholarship in academic journals laurel e. This is an insightful analysis of one of the most fundamental political science issues of our times how the emerging democracies in eastern europe and elsewhere should deal with the legal systems inherited from their authoritarian pasts. According to jon elster, transitional justice is, made up of the process of trials, purges, and reparations that take place after the transition from one political regime to another elster 2004, p 1, while ruti teitel applies the term to a shift in political orders a bounded period, spanning two regimesteitel 2000. Introduction this article proposes a genealogy of transitional justice. Ruti teitel explores the recurring dilemma of how regimes should respond to evil rule, arguing against the prevailing view favoring punishment, yet contending that the law nevertheless plays a. Core principles of tranformative justice are synthesized from various theorists. Transitional justice stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Global civil society and transitional justice springerlink.
Global transitional justice george mason university. Oxford transitional justice research otjr invites to. The author defines transitional justice as a framework to solve the fundamental problems of society, in. The power and politics of transitional justice justice. Relationship of international criminal justice to transitional justice and to restorative justice. Weinstein abstract this article examinestransitional justice scholarship published in academic periodicals overa sixyear period, 20032008, to identify the disciplinesthat contributed to the.
Transitional justice takes this question to a new level with an interdisciplinary approach that challenges the very terms of the. The law and politics of comtemporary transitional justice. At any such time of radical change, the question arises. For the united nations, transitional justice is the full range of processes. Transitional justice takes the debate to a new level with an interdisciplinary approach that challenges the very terms of the contemporary debate. Ruti teitel has outlined a threestage transitional justice genealogy. Transitional justice is an emerging domain of inquiry that has gained importance with the regime changes in latin america after the 1970s, the collapse of the european and soviet communist regimes. Ruti teitel explores the ways in which a society should respond to evil rule. Teitel description at the centurys end, societies all over the world are throwing off the yoke of authoritarian rule and beginning to build democracies. She has worked with the liberian truth and reconciliation commission in ghana and liberia, and also completed the arthur liman public interest fellowship at the international center. Such measures include criminal prosecutions, truth commissions, reparations programs, and various kinds of institutional reforms.
This article uses the trials of slobodan milosevic and saddam hussein as an occasion for revisiting and extending my ongoing project of tracing a genealogy of transitional justice. United states institute of peace transitional justice. Theory and practice 409 raised in october 2009 by the president of the icty, patrick robinson, who suggested establishing a claims commission, through which victims would be able to lodge compensation claims. In addition to judicial mechanisms, gross human rights violations can also be addressed through broader transitional justice measures. In prior work, i have defined transitional justice as that conception of. Other transitional policies include administrative purges, the opening of archives, reparations and the creation of public monuments. Kara apland joins jic for a guestpost on transitional justice. Teitel explores the recurring question of how regimes should respond to evil rule, arguing against the prevailing view favoring punishment, and contending through historical and comparative. Transitional justice at crossroads the landmark verdict of the supreme court sc of nepal on 2 january 2014 has signaled a significant breakthrough in relation to transitional justice debates in nepal. In the declaration of the highlevel meeting on the rule of.
Transitional justice united nations and the rule of law. Summary of transitional justice beyond intractability. Negotiating transitional justice berghof foundation. Cornell international law journal world history, a framework proposed for the study of the law and politics of transitional justice. The emergence of a paradigm the concept of transitional justice stems from the international human rights movement. This chapter briefly presents both fields so as to clarify how they have developed and how they are linked. See recently jens iverson, transitional justice, jus post bellum and international criminal law. An overview of the history and theory of transformative.
As transitions to democracy have become more common, transitional justice has become a significant issue in many instances. On the long run, their work is crucial to reestablish the rule of law and public trust towards the state. Transitional justice and the protection of economic, social and cultural rights have gained momentum in the past two decades. Teitel summary written by eric brahm, conflict research consortium citation. Transitional justice theories transitional justice theories is the. Nevertheless, little attention has been given to the links between them.
Judicial measures like trials and legal reforms, and nonjudicial measures like truth commissions and compensation schemes can and should complement each other. Notes to transitional justice stanford encyclopedia of. Routledges transitional justice series publishes innovative work across a range of disciplines working on transitional justice related topics. Nocella ii abstract this article is dedicated to the historical overview, political development, and philosophy of transformative justice, with a primary focus on the united states. At the centurys end, societies all over the world are throwing off the yoke of authoritarian rule and beginning to build democracies.
Transitional justice is enacted at a point of political transition from violence and repression to societal stability or at times. A lasting legacy of the nuremberg and tokyo military tribunals is the. The law and politics of contemporary transitional justice. Transitional justice globalized by ruti teitel ssrn. Transitional justice is a response to systematic or widespread violations of human rights. Depending on these conditions as well as on the nature of crimes committed, transitional justice should attempt to confront impunity, seek effective redress for victims and prevent future atrocities. An introduction to some issues in transitional justice diva portal. In 1991, at the time of the soviet collapse and following the latin american transitions to democracy in the 1980s, teitel coined the term transitional justice to.
It combines contributions from distinguished scholars and practitioners as well as from emerging academics from different disciplines. The note is informed by the guidance note of the secretarygeneral on united nations approach to rule of law assistance. I have decided to concentrate on war crime tribunals and truth commissions both because these are the most frequently used instruments other policies. Teitel takes an interdisciplinary approach to examine key debates. Differentiating the usages, history and dynamics, 7 intl j transitional justice 20 4 arguing that a too broad definition of transitional justice, so as to include international criminal law and ius post bellum, decreases the potentiality of the three concepts. The reasons for this disconnect are multifold, including the fact that the two fields stem from traditionally distinct fields of scholarship and practicetransitional. An introduction to some issues in transitional justice. The origins of modern transitional justice can be traced to world war i.
Justice research otjr invites to transitional justice. For a comprehensive analysis of transitional justice, see ruti g. Events may have taken place far in the past, which makes finding information extremely difficult. Transitional justice, international law and the united. Transitional justice is an expression i coined in 1991 at the time of the soviet collapse and on the heels of the late 1980s latin american transitions to democracy. Provides an interdisciplinary perspective deriving from many different national and regional contexts, and spanning the range of institutions and policy responses. It seeks recog nition for victims and promotion of possibilities for peace, reconciliation and democracy. Transitional justice is not a special form of justice but justice adapted to societies transforming themselves after. Kara recently completed a fulbright scholarship studying human rights at the london school of economics and political science. When peter asked me to participate in this colloquium as commentator on ruti teitels paper, it seemed to me a very nice idea. Although transregime legitimation is certainly not transitional justice s only role, it is an important function and provides resources for a unified political theory of transitional justice. At first, it referred to the judicial process of addressing human rights violations committed by. Fuller debate and law in transitional societies martin krygier my assignment in this session is a little problematic. Transitional justice in practice new tactics in human rights.
1455 1260 184 963 1511 954 1137 684 349 589 1031 581 212 915 1069 461 794 857 825 888 420 32 328 338 301 240 508 1401 209 479 1171 1413 918 887 661 88 1002 12 1474 214 1087 208 1417 89